Wake up, BP, and Restore Wyoming’s Soda Lake

Wake up, BP, and Restore Wyoming’s Soda Lake

Page 3

Immediately BP replaced Amoco’s environmental manager who hadn’t done much for cleanup with a can-do wildlife advocate named Joe Deschamp. Rea, who had been appointed by the Joint Powers Board to a subcommittee charged with enhancing wetlands, worked with Deschamp to make habitat in and around Soda Lake even more productive and, at the same time, turn the area into a wildlife education center. BP created the nesting islands Rea and I had walked to, protected them from wave erosion with uncontaminated concrete refinery rubble, and protected nesters from foxes and coyotes by digging deep, encircling trenches. It erected osprey platforms and developed walking trails and a road system. So impressed by Deschamp’s crew and their work was Audubon’s then president, John Flicker, that he wrote in an email to Bart Rea in 2000: “I think the BP people I talked with are ready to do more than just fencing, blinds, and access roads at Soda Lake. They would like to be associated with Audubon education as their image, not as toxic polluters, and I think they are willing to pay what it takes to make that happen.”

For the remediation project BP (along with its collaborators, most notably the Wyoming Department of Environmental Quality and the Joint Powers Board) received Wyoming’s Recognition of Accomplishment Award, two EPA National Notable Achievement Awards, two EPA Environmental Achievement Awards, the Wyoming Engineering Society’s Presidential Project Award, and the American Council of Engineering Companies’ Grand Award.

This aberrant display of corporate responsibility on the part of a major energy company might be explained with three words: Lord John Browne. Browne, an ardent environmentalist, was a board member of Birdlife International and BP’s CEO. He spoke proudly of his company’s work at Soda Lake, and under his watch BP did things like donate 29,000 acres in Alberta to the Nature Conservancy of Canada. “No damage to the natural environment” was his command to his employees.

But in 2007 Deschamp retired, and Browne, accused of sexual improprieties, resigned. Again, the attitude changed almost overnight. BP transferred its refinery site and non-producing, sensitive properties to Atlantic Richfield (which it had recently acquired), and its interest in wildlife evaporated like spit on a glowing wood stove.

 

In 2008 pumping to Soda Lake ceased. This despite the fact that the company had assured the environmental community that it would maintain Soda Lake’s level as long as it treated groundwater effluent—80 to 100 years. Instead, with a permit from the DEQ, BP started dumping the groundwater into the golf course ponds and river. In the treatment process it currently recovers and sells about 40,000 gallons of oil per month.

Two years before it permanently weaned Soda Lake of water, BP had sponsored a tour for local wildlife advocates. Participating was Brian Rutledge, executive director of Audubon Wyoming and National Audubon’s vice president for the Rocky Mountain Region. BP had lowered the lake to dredge the inlet basin, but it informed Rutledge that it was finishing up its work and would soon raise the water level for the benefit of wildlife. “We were taken to the nesting islands,” he said. “We were told that the lake would soon be up and the islands would be islands again. Since then the lake has been drying up, and we haven’t heard a peep from BP.”

BP’s excuse for shutting off the flow was an alleged leak or leaks in the pipeline (buried only about four feet in the ground) that it hadn’t been able to locate and that no one else had heard about. As surprised as anyone was Pete Ramirez, environmental contaminants specialist for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, who has advised BP and the Wyoming DEQ on the ecological risks of a dewatered Soda Lake. “The documents for the risk assessment, the remediation, and all the stuff done through the collaborative process—everything they put out said the pipeline was in okay shape,” he says.

And Rea offers this: “Why did they decide to quit doing what they said they were going to do? Because the pipeline is leaking and they can’t find where? Well, that’s ridiculous. That’s not a valid reason.”

Deschamp declined to tell me what he thinks about BP’s decision to deep-six all his hard, expensive work and thereby extinguish this essential waterfowl, wading bird, and shorebird habitat. BP’s press office was unable to give me a contact person but assured me that someone would get back to me. No one did. Finally, I tracked down Chuck Stilwell in Anchorage, Alaska, as far as I could determine the last person to serve in Deschamp’s former capacity. Stilwell informed me that he no longer had responsibility for Casper but gave me an Illinois phone number for one David Clauson, who supposedly is now in charge. Clauson didn’t return my phone calls.

When I asked Stilwell why BP had decided to let Soda Lake dry up, he said this: “There are always several options for dealing with water coming from the remediation work. One is to pump it to Soda Lake. The other is to put it into the North Platte River near the site for water-rights users. There are costs and benefits to both choices. The local governmental representatives actually preferred it to go into the river.” I was unable to uncover a shred of evidence that this is the case, but I did learn that Soda Lake’s annual water requirement is so minuscule that water-rights holders along the North Platte would basically be unaffected. He went on to say that the pipeline “could [my emphasis] have been in serious shape,” that BP’s “understanding was that it was leaking,” that replacing it would have been “quite expensive,” and that BP might consider “putting in guzzlers for upland game and upland birds.”

 

Magazine Category

Author Profile

Ted Williams

Ted Williams is freelance writer.

Type: Author | From: Audubon Magazine

Comments

Wholesale Jerseys China

The Ravens began to use the clock against the 49ers, running the ball and calling short passing plays as they drove 59 yards over 10 plays, chewing five minutes and 38 seconds off the clock before Tucker kicked a 38-yard field goal to give the Ravens a 34-29 lead, forcing the 49ers to score a late touchdown to win the game.? Photos: Power outage interrupts third quarter of Super BowlBill Callahan [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale Jerseys From China[/url] denies allegations he "sabotaged" Raiders in Super Bowl [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale NFL Jerseys[/url] XXXVII (USA Today Sports Images)Former Oakland Raiders head coach Bill Callahan issued a statement to ESPN on Tuesday denying allegations from wide receivers Tim Brown and Jerry Rice that [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale Jerseys Cheap[/url] he "sabotaged" the Raiders in Super Bowl XXXVII.

Wholesale Jerseys China

Regardless of the actual NFL鈥檚 ongoing utilization of the actual WPT like a way of measuring cognitive capability, absolutely no medical assistance from the Raymond Felton Jersey WPT like a predictor associated with NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE achievement may be supplied by possibly the actual NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE or even the actual Wonderlic business (Lyons, Michel & Hoffman, 2005). Additional, overview of the actual books discovered just 2 research which have analyzed the power from the WPT in order to forecast expert soccer achievement. Within the very first research the actual WPT outcomes of 261 NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE gamers chosen within the 2002 write had been related along with NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE overall performance with regard to 2002 as well as 2003. Overall performance information had been placement particular; for instance overall performance requirements for that quarterback placement incorporated the actual NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE quarterback score (discussed inside a later on section); Patrick Ewing Jersey requirements for that operating back again placement incorporated back yards acquired, move receptions as well as back Carmelo Anthony Jersey yards, as well as touchdowns.

Cheap Jerseys China

Granted, Gendreau's sexual orientation does place the NFL, or specific teams, in an awkward position. No matter whether he's signed or not signed, offered a tryout or not, meaning will accrue. Teams will be accused of pandering, or discriminating, no matter what [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale NFL Jerseys Free Shipping[/url] they do. Still, this is the way that barriers break down.Gendreau, who does not yet have an agent, will try to score an invite to a team's OTA (organized team activity) over the next couple months. Barring that, he can try to work his way into an NFL training camp in July or August. The odds are long, but many observers believe Gendreau has both the talent and the open-mindedness [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale NFL Jerseys China[/url] to reach the NFL."It's totally legit that he can get into the league," Minnesota Vikings punter Chris Kluwe, a proponent of gay rights, [url=http://www.wholesalejerseyschinastore.us/]Wholesale Jerseys From China[/url] told Outsports. "Place-kicking is all about doing this one specific skill set. And if you can do that, you can make it whether you獫e been out of football for one year or 10 years."

コーチ メンズ Teenosoidge

http://www.kochifield.com/ Save marriage counseling might help to uncover some some other problems or issues and understand the troubles connected with couple. The wife may become depressed or husband sometimes have the problems with stress. [url=http://www.kochifield.com/]コーチ アウトレット[/url] Since counseling does not make an effort to resolve [url=http://www.kochifield.com/]コーチ 財布[/url] the issues like depression or anxiety, it can uncover these issues [url=http://www.kochifield.com/]コーチ バッグ[/url] and helps to seek the treatment with regard to them.
http://www.kochigirl.com It can also assist in identify the [url=http://www.kochigirl.com]コーチ アウトレット[/url] differences between the couples and manage with them.[url=http://www.kochigirl.com]コーチのアウトレット[/url] It offers a good possibility to the couples to reveal their feelings [url=http://www.kochigirl.com]coach アウトレット[/url] and helps clear all misunderstandings.
http://www.kochitokyo.com/ The effects of save marriage counseling are simply to be wonderful. [url=http://www.kochitokyo.com/]コーチ アウトレット[/url] After seeking this direction, many [url=http://www.kochitokyo.com/]コーチ バッグ[/url] couples have happen to be successful in resolving conflicts in their married [url=http://www.kochitokyo.com/]コーチ 財布[/url] life and 've back to a content married life.

オークリー サングラス Eximiteerbent

http://www.oakleyjpmax.com/ Quick: What's the difference among a PET scan as well as a CAT scan? Or HDL and LDL cholesterol? If you're like many people, you may not always be sureyou leave the medspeak (and also screening decisions) towards pros. In fact, 70 percent [url=http://www.oakleysite.com/]オークリー サングラス[/url] of Americans put blind faith into their doctors and opt out of researching their advice or perhaps getting second opinions. But disquieting studies indicate you'd be [url=http://www.oakleyjpmax.com/]オークリー サングラス[/url] smart to keep an eye on your own treatment. General practitioners are now shouldering lots more patientsthe average family medical doctor sees 20 a daywhich may produce rushed visits and inadvertent slips. And all types of [url=http://www.oakleysite.com/]オークリー ジョウボーン[/url] physicians might engage in, intentionally or not, some [url=http://www.oakleyjpmax.com/]オークリー ゴルフ[/url] badforyou behavior. To protect yourself, stay two steps well before docs who are.. In fact, from 1999 through '09, the number of solutions doctors wrote rose 39 %, perhaps unnecessarily. (The number associated with sleepingpill scripts, for example, has grown 21 times more rapidly than reported sleeplessness issues, according to the U . s citizens Journal of Public Health and wellbeing.) Unfortunately, reaching for a compose and prescription pad is normally easier than searching intended for intel on whether the healthier alternative exists. Sleep Deprived

http://www.oakleysite.com/ Pilots are required to log at the least 10 hours of offduty time period between flights, but there's no such clearcut rule for medical professionals, who [url=http://www.oakleyjpmax.com/]オークリー メガネ[/url] also take lives for their handssometimes while on 24hour adjusts. Their [url=http://www.oakleyjpmax.com/]オークリー ゴーグル[/url] lack of shuteye will surely have scary repercussions: Surgeons who got lower than six hours of sleeping the night before in a encountered roughly twice as much operation complications as his or her wellrested peers, according to the [url=http://www.oakleynihonn.com/]オークリー[/url] Journal of the American Medical Association.

http://www.oakleynihonn.com/ Take Care: "It is absolutely in your rights to ask your doctor what their own sleep is like, especially before a surgery treatment, " says Landrigan. When booking a system, query your doc in relation to his oncall scheduleand pick a surgical procedure date [url=http://www.oakleysite.com/]オークリー アウトレット[/url] before a lengthy shift starts. Likewise, opt for the original morning appointment possible, before [url=http://www.oakleynihonn.com/]オークリー サングラス[/url] he is exhausted from the full day of sufferer woes. And if you need to make an unexpected trip into the ER and find yourself using a drowsy resident or going to [url=http://www.oakleynihonn.com/]オークリー ゴーグル[/url] physician, ask to be found by another doctor.

http://socialjusticehistory.org/projects/readers/index.php?title=To_safe....

http://sq.mormonwiki.com/Faqja_Kryesore

http://wiki.sidewaykill.com/index.php?title=There_are_many_lenders_out_t....

soda lake

BP's responses to the concern expressed by Ted Williams article “Wake Up, BP” and many other readers is so typical of the big conglomerate companies justifying their actions or inaction's. It shows in other projects throughout the country; ie, 'Gasland' the documentary on fracking throughout Wyoming, Montana and many other states. It seems as though money is the lord of the multi-national companies, which give way to lies and twisted truths . . . it is heartless and contrary to the natural order of life. If anyone tries to come out of the mire and report 'truth' they are shoved down in an their effort to keep their voices silent.
We have to be thankful of the internet, which is a wonderful way to voice our concerns and outrage. We collectively realize we are not alone in our frustrations.
So . . . let OUR voices be heard LOUD and CLEAR continually. If we 'beat' upon the door it will gradually weaken and break down.
Keep up the good work Audubon!!

Soda Lake and BP response

Ms. Viso,
I know you're just an employee of this megalopolis called BP, and you're going to spin what ever the management instructs. But pass on this message to your management superiors: Environmental advocates will continue to have a powerful lobby and voice, and one day, in the not so distant future, your company will suffer if you do not follow through on the concerns of Soda Lake, and other places like it in a world that have suffered through poor management decisions by your company.
The winds of change are blowing through this country, and a day of reckoning is coming. One day, we with environmental concerns will have the majority votes in Congress. We will not forget those who were not cooperative with our concerns, and who had the ability to affect a positive change in our world, and yet did nothing.

response to BP on Soda Lake

I received the same response from BP that is listed above and I responded:

Ms. Viso,
I know you're just an employee of this megalopolis called BP, and you're going to spin what ever the management instructs. But pass on this message to your management superiors: Environmental advocates will continue to have a powerful lobby and voice, and one day, in the not so distant future, your company will suffer if you do not follow through on the concerns of Soda Lake, and other places like it in a world that have suffered through poor management decisions by your company.
The winds of change are blowing through this country, and a day of reckoning is coming. One day, we with environmental concerns will have the majority votes in Congress. We will not forget those who were not cooperative with our concerns, and who had the ability to affect a positive change in our world, and yet did nothing.

Wake Up BP

Isn't this an issue of "water rights"? The clue is in BP's reply below:

· The available water rights are significant and are being assigned to the city of Casper and Natrona County, consistent with a 1998 agreement with those local government entities. This allows the local government entities, citizens and stakeholders in the greater Casper area to determine the most beneficial use of this valuable resource, and not BP.

If so, shouldn't Audubon be lobbying the "local government entities" concerned to grant BP sufficient water to flood Soda Lake? It's not clear that the supposedly defective pipeline has anything to do with the decision. The statement, here, that "BP may also use some of the treated groundwater to irrigate the golf course" suggests where the priorities of these "entities" may lie!

The following comments were made by a friend after having done a bit of research.

PS: the attached file, REMEDY DECISION FOR THE FORMER BP CASPER REFINERY
SODA LAKE AREA, from Wyoming Department of Environmental Quality, lays out the background and, in pp56-61, sets out BP's obligations and "describes the selected remedy for the Inlet Basin sediments impacted by refinery operations" that required lowering the water level. Subsequent restoration of the water level does not appear to be mandated without agreement from all parties, hence BP's response quoted above.

RD3final011002.pdf

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.